Current:Home > reviewsJohnathan Walker:She was the face of grief after 4 family members slain. Now she's charged with murder. -Capitatum
Johnathan Walker:She was the face of grief after 4 family members slain. Now she's charged with murder.
Surpassing Quant Think Tank Center View
Date:2025-04-06 08:17:12
When Amy Vilardi spoke publicly about brutal slayings of four family members found slain inside their South Carolina home on Johnathan WalkerHalloween seven years ago, she thanked the community for their prayers and shamed the killer for their "vicious'" deaths.
“I would like to point out how wonderful everyone in this community has been," she told The Independent Mail, part of the USA TODAY NETWORK after the killings. "All of our great friends and the amazing family we love so very much, praying for us.”
“I don’t understand why any of it has happened and I just keep thinking it’s a dream I’m going to wake up from,” Vilardi told local WYFF-TV several days after the 2015 killings. “Whoever did this, I don’t see how you can live with yourself.”
In a twist, Anderson County Sheriff Chad McBride announced Friday Vilardi and her husband, Rosmore "Ross" Vilardi, had been charged with multiple counts of murder in connection to the 2015 quadruple "senseless and brutal" killing he said rocked the county "to its core."
During a press conference, the sheriff told reporters the couple was arrested at their home in Columbia, S.C. and transported back to Anderson County where online jail records show they remained held without bond Wednesday − each charged with four counts of murder.
A brutal quadruple killing in a small, rural town
Cathy Scott, 60, and her husband Mike Scott, 59, and their mothers Barbara Scott, 80, and Violet Taylor, 82 were all violently killed on Oct. 31, 2015 in their rural home in the small town of Pendleton, located upstate near Clemson University.
According to the last U.S. Census, its population at the time consisted of less than 3,500 residents and the town is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
The sheriff has not said what led investigators to the suspects or why it took so to charge them. More information will likely be revealed in court during the couple's preliminary hearing, which Anderson County court records show is set early next year.
"I think we knew this day would come," McBride said. "We were praying this day would come.... We've had some really good prayers answered.”
'I did her a favor':Woman sentenced to prison after tossing dog off parking garage roof to death
Dead for several hours, 'maybe several days'
According to police, on the afternoon of the killings, Amy Vilardi called 911 and reported she found the victims dead, the USA TODAY NETWORK, reported at the time.
Investigators said the victims were likely dead for several hours, "maybe several days"," before their bodies were discovered.
Shortly after the killings, Anderson County Coroner Greg Shore said what happened inside the home was one of "the worst cases he had seen in decades" as all the victims were apparently shot quickly." and "No one had the chance to escape."
“This was a vicious, vicious killing,” Shore told the USA TODAY NETWORK.
Three victims were discovered in the den and Cathy Scott's body was found in her bedroom, officials said.
Based on a 'false, racist claim':Boston mayor apologizes for city's handling of 1989 murder case.
Lawsuit filed against the sheriff's office to return nearly $90K in cash taken
It was not immediately known if the Vilardis had obtained an attorney, but the couple previously denied any involvement in the killings.
At the time of the killings, the couple lived in another home on the same property, and remained in the home for at least a year after the fatal attacks.
Months after the killings, the Vilardis sued the sheriff’s office, "seeking the return of vehicles and electronics and nearly $90,000 in cash that were taken from the two homes by investigators."
According to the suit, obtained by the USA TODAY NETWORK, items have no value as evidence and are in danger of being destroyed or otherwise lost to the Vilardis. The Sheriff’s Office is believed to have “performed numerous tests and analyses on the currency, specifically, and has found no DNA or other evidence linking the plaintiffs to any wrongdoing,” according to the lawsuit, which was filed in late May 2016.
But the USA TODAY NETWORK reported the sheriff's office said, "only a single test for blood was done on the currency, in a June response to the lawsuit. The Sheriff’s Office has acted in good faith and in line with law enforcement practices, including obtaining warrants, to take the items as evidence, according to the response that seeks to have the case dismissed."
In a Facebook message to a reporter with the USA TODAY NETWORK in late 2016, Amy Vilardi wrote she had not "heard any significant updates on the homicide case, or the lawsuit, in months."
“I am myself without much information,” she said at the time. “I would like to point out how wonderful everyone in this community has been. All of our great friends and the amazing family we love so very much, praying for us.”
The Vilardis, are slated to appear in Anderson County Criminal Court for a preliminary hearing on the murder charges on Feb. 20.
Contributing: Mike Ellis, Nikie Mayor with The Independent Mail.
Natalie Neysa Alund is a senior reporter for USA TODAY. Reach her at [email protected] and follow her on X @nataliealund.
veryGood! (52931)
Related
- Rolling Loud 2024: Lineup, how to stream the world's largest hip hop music festival
- Jail where Trump will be booked in Georgia has long been plagued with violence
- Causeway: Part stock fund + part donor-advised fund = A new bid for young donors
- Man fatally shot by officer after police say he pointed a gun at another person and ran
- Southern California rocked by series of earthquakes: Is a bigger one brewing?
- Notre Dame vs. Navy in Ireland: Game time, how to watch, series history and what to know
- Japanese farmer has fought for decades to stay on his ancestral land in the middle of Narita airport
- Fit for Tony Stark: Powerball winner’s California mansion once listed at $88 million
- Meta donates $1 million to Trump’s inauguration fund
- Southern Indiana egg farmer John Rust announces bid for Republican nod for US Senate in 2024.
Ranking
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- Sexism almost sidelined Black women at 1963 March on Washington. How they fought back.
- Obamas' beloved chef died of accidental drowning, autopsy confirms
- First GOP debate kicks off in Milwaukee with attacks on Biden, Trump absent from the stage
- Taylor Swift Cancels Austria Concerts After Confirmation of Planned Terrorist Attack
- Sneak peek at 'The Hill' baseball movie: First look at emotional Dennis Quaid scene
- Theodore Roosevelt presidential library taking shape in North Dakota Badlands
- Listen to Taylor Swift's Re-Recorded Version of Look What You Made Me Do in Wilderness Teaser
Recommendation
FACT FOCUS: Inspector general’s Jan. 6 report misrepresented as proof of FBI setup
Giuliani is expected to turn himself in on Georgia 2020 election indictment charges
Texas defends border buoys at hearing over Justice Department lawsuit
Van poof! Dutch e-bike maker VanMoof goes bankrupt, leaving riders stranded
Residents worried after ceiling cracks appear following reroofing works at Jalan Tenaga HDB blocks
As Ralph Yarl begins his senior year of high school, the man who shot him faces a court hearing
Larsa Pippen and Marcus Jordan Set the Record Straight on Their Relationship Status
Notre Dame vs. Navy in Ireland: Game time, how to watch, series history and what to know